Subscribe to the RSS Feed

Contempt of Court in Ohio Custody, Shared Parenting and Visitation Cases: Part 4

December 27, 2010

This is the 4th installment in a series about enforcing visitation with Contempt written by Virginia Cornwell.  Virginia is a A Franklin County Ohio Custody Lawyer and Ohio State Bar Association Certified Family Relations Specialist.  Virginia is one of approximate 100 attorneys in Ohio to have received this honor.

The other articles in the contempt series can be seen below:

DEFENSES TO CONTEMPT THAT ARE NOT LIKELY TO WORK IN OHIO

In the course of this series, we’ve already discussed one defense to contempt that rarely works in Ohio, that a motion to modify the order was pending while a person continued to violate the order.    Ohio Revised Code 2705.031 provides that a court can find a person in contempt, and punish them accordingly, even if the court later decides to change the order.  (See ORC 2705.05 .  Click here to see our post on penalties.

In other cases, the parties, and even the attorneys may mistakenly believe that if they take the positions that they were following the advice of their attorney, they cannot or will not be held in contempt.  This is not true. It is no defense to a finding of contempt that a party acted in good faith or upon the advice of counsel. See Polk v. PolkRini v. Dyer, 2008-Ohio-4172, Miller v. Miller, State Ex Rel Adkins v. Sobb, Townsend v. Townsend, Pugh v. Pugh, 15 Ohio St. 3d 136 – Ohio: Supreme Court 198 etc.

Other excuses which don’t hold a lot of water in Ohio are excuses which put the wishes of the child above the order of the court, convenient ( and non-existent illnesses), convenient work and car problems that only seem to occur at the time for exchanges, etc.

Some persons who do not obey court orders mistakenly believe that they cannot be sentenced to jail time in a civil contempt action.  To put it another way, they believe that the imposition of jail time makes the action a criminal contempt action, as opposed to a civil contempt action, and that he or she now has all the rights of a criminal defendant.  This is not the case.  In a civil contempt case, the purpose of the punishment is to coerce the contemnor to obey a judicial order for the benefit of a third party.  See Polk v. Polk, Carroll v. Detty.  In addition, civil contempt sanctions are conditional in nature, since the contemnor (person in contempt) is said to carry the keys to his or her prison in their pocket – because the court gives them a chance to purge their contempt (obey the court order) before they go to jail. State v. Kilbane, 61 Ohio St. 2d 201.  NOTE:  Purging contempt will not save you from fines, attorney fees, and a possible change of custody, just from prison.

Another legal argument that fails is the argument that jail time for contempt violates the constitutional prohibition against imprisonment for debts.  WRONG.  See Pugh v. Pugh, 15 Ohio St. 3d 136 – Ohio: Supreme Court 198 and Harris v. Harris (1979), 58 Ohio St. 2d 303 [12 O.O.3d 291].

One thing that it is important to remember is that if the other parent fails to transport the child, you can seek to hold them in contempt for failing to do so, but you need to go ahead and do the driving and/ or make the transportation arrangements yourself, unless it is impossible (not inconvenient) to do so on in the time frame remaining for the visitation.  Try not to worry about the unfairness of having to do all the driving yourself  - courts have remedies available for parents who WILL NOT (as opposed to can not) exchange their child, such as a change in custody.

DISCLAIMER

Leave a Comment

WARNING!!!!! DO NOT INCLUDE ANY INFORMATION ABOUT YOUR SITUATION, ONLY COMMENTS. COMMENTS AND QUESTIONS WILL NOT BE KEPT CONFIDENTIAL, AND WILL BE POSTED FOR EVERYONE TO SEE. THERE IS NO ATTORNEY-CLIENT RELATIONSHIP FORMED BY POSTING ON THIS BLOG AND NO PRIVACY FOR COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS. QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS POSTED ON THE BLOG WILL NOT BE ANSWERED, BUT IF WE GET ENOUGH QUESTIONS ABOUT THE SAME TOPIC WE MIGHT WRITE AN ARTICLE ON THE TOPIC. OKAY, NOW THAT THE IMPORTANT BLAH, BLAH, BLAH IS DONE, HERE'S THE REST: IF OUR WEBSITE HELPED YOU, WE'D APPRECIATE A SHOUT OUT. GIVE US A LINK, GIVE US A REVIEW, LIKE US ON FACEBOOK, OR TELL A FRIEND. IN FACT, TELL ALL YOUR FRIENDS!

1 P

How many contempt violations need to occur before the offending parent is punished, e.g., 1,2 maybe 9? Two Lawyers in Lucas County Ohio say the offending parent will only have to give additional parenting time. What needs to occur before the offending parent is truly punished?

2 g

In a criminal contempt case over visitation issues, do u have the right to have a jury trial?

3 KR

How many times of a parent not taking their child/children to their sporting events is needed before filing contempt. Along with how many months are needed to pass of not getting ANY telephone time with my children is needed and how long does he have to pay the 50% of all extra ciricular activites and medical expenses not covered by the insurance. How long do I need to track this before appearing back in court? I don’t want to look petty. I take this seriously these are my children. How do I get an attorney to take me seriously? PLEASE HELP with suggestions.

4 Anonymous

I am with the non residential parent below but I am the residential parent who moved away to start again, away from harassment and abuse of myself and child.
My child’s parent does not respond to meet halfway and will sometimes email saying he will but never gets back with me. I’m forced to do all the driving or get my family involved in meeting me halfway because he will not. This has gone on for over a year. Oh, and he is never current on child support. Gotta love Ohio for that not being relevant.

5 Anonymous

I was wondering what you meant by “Try not to worry about the unfairness of having to do all the driving yourself – courts have remedies available for parents who WILL NOT (as opposed to can not) exchange their child, such as a change in custody.” Does this mean that the non-residential parent does NOT have to do all the driving? Especially in the case where the residential parent moved away, therefore increasing the drive time, and decreasing the amount of time actually spent with the child? The residential parent refuses to come to an agreement to meet 1/2 way or even less than 1/2 way in their case.

Your articles have provided some great insight! Thank you!

6 Anonymous

This information was very helpful thank you!!

7 L

I am wondering if there is some kind of law that I need to know about for an upcoming court date. My former husband has filed several contempt charges against me, several times, all have been dropped when I appear in court. This next court date is yet another example of his attempts in harassing me. He makes a lot of money, I don’t.
Specifically, I was wondering if again I am not guilty of these charges of contempt, is there a law that states, he pays my attorney fees? I truly believe this ongoing situation would stop if he had to pay my attorney fees.
I thank you in advance for any advice.

Previous post:

Next post: